A DIALOGUE BETWEEN A BROWNIST and a SCHISMATICK.
WEll met holy Brother Schiſmatick, I hope our meeting will prove profitable to our own ſelves, the Edification of our Church and deſtruction and rooting out the Papiſticall Doctrine of the Whoriſh and Idolatrous Church of Rome, and formall Proteſtancy little better then Popery, from being any more uſed in England, or any of his Majeſties Dominions.
Thou haſt ſpoken very religiouſly, and haſt manifeſted thy ſelf to be a good Zelot, in the cauſe of righteouſnes, and am I right ioy2 full ſo happily here in this place to meet with you, where I hope we without fear may ſpeak freely of the preſent affairs of State, and of reducing our Religion and manner of worſhipping to its former purity and glory; but to beginne our diſcourſe, how may theſe our pious intentions be effected?
Truely brother I conceave no readier and eaſier way to effect this holy worke then to agree in outward appearance, for to promote Truth and Religion, we may warrantably uſe diſſimulation, as we have many examples in Scripture, David diſſembled himſelf for the ſafety of his life to the King of Lachiſh: Abraham diſſembled to King Abimelech, and taught his wife to lie, for the preſervation of her chaſtity: and Ioſeph diſſembled to his brethren, to the end to make them to underſtand their former wickedneſſe committed againſt him: the Harlot Rachel hid the ſpies ſent from Ioſuah and diſſembled the ſame, with a lie for her excuſe: many ſuch like examples I might produce, to warrant diſſimulation ſometimes in a good cauſe, for I ſay for the promotion of this〈◊〉holy a work we may joyne our ſelves in league and fraternity with Anabaptiſts, Seperatrſts, and when we have accompliſhed our deſires we may ſhake off their ſociety, or indeavour to reduce them to an uniformity with us, being now neereſt us in opinion, of any profeſſion, and ſo may the eaſier be drawn from their opinions that differ from ours.
Indeed I do approve of thy reſolution, but I conceave it beſt in the firſt place, to ſpeake of the manner and forme of diſcipline and worſhip in Religion, and then they who will agree and ſide with us, ſo ſhall we the better know which is the ſafeſt way to proceed in,3 and firſt let us begin what forme of diſcipline we ſhould have uſed in the exerciſe of our Religion, and what Doctrine is beſt to be receaved in the Church; and finally, what forme of government is meeteſt to be uſed and eſtabliſhed for the eſtabliſhment thereof, and therefore I pray ſhew thy opinion of the Common Prayer now uſed; and what forme of prayer is meeteſt to be uſed, that may agree with the ſpirit; by which we ought to be directed and inſtructed.
Verily brother touching the Common prayer now uſed, it is no wayes to be allowed or received in the Church, being altogether Superſtitious, and Idolatrous, the inventions of men, and not made by the holy ſpirit, but onely inſtituted by Papiſts and Popiſhly affected Prelates.
I confeſſe great part of the Letany is ſuperfluous and ſuperſtitious, but I think there be many prayers in the book that were indicted by the Spirit of God, and made by holy men, which were approved and continually uſed in the time of Edward the ſixth and Queen Elizabeth; are theſe to be rejected and diſallowed, after the long uſage of the ſame in the Church and not diſallowed in the reign of King Iames, in whoſe time many differences and contentions were raiſed about the ſame by the Clergy of thoſe times?
The reaſon why a through reformation of the book of Common Prayer hath not yet been admitted to this day, was the great troubles that have been raiſed in this kingdome by the Romiſh faction, after Queen Mary moſt part of this kingdom then acknowledging the idolatrous Doctrine of that Antichriſt, and Man of ſinne, the Biſhop of Rome, which in all the time of Queen Elizabeth could4 not be purged, our Religion being then ſcarce known and altogether diſliked, and in the time of King Iames, the pride and haughtineſſe of the Clergy more inclined to Popery then Purity, hindered a through Reformation, although our profeſſion began then to take head and gather ſome ſtrength and approbation in this kingdom, many opinions and tenents that we had being approved of the King himſelf, but now the purity and ſincerity of our religion being accepted and acknowledged in moſt parts of the kingdom eſpecially in the chief Cities & Corporations thereof, it is our duty to ſtudy a through Reformation in time, leſt we be by the adverſaries of truth and piety ſuppreſſed, and no meanes left for the eſtabliſhing of the ſame; and for thoſe prayers you mentioned, ſome of them may be ſtill retained and uſed in the Church, which I will againſt the next meeting extract from the reſt.
Enough at this time of the Common Prayer, let me have your opinion touching what Doctrine, now acknowledged in our Church, is meet to be purged, and diſcipline for the exerciſe thereof.
That will I do: The Doctrine of Baptiſme with the Croſſe I utterly deny and diſallow, Marriage with a hoop Ring, and the like; but for Diſcipline in the manner of Worſhip, I diſallow the uſe of Surplice, &c. I would have us follow the example of Chriſt in all things as near as we can, and let his example be our rule to walk by; If he taught in the Temples, let us make uſe of Temples and Churches for teaching and inſtruction; if he taught in ſhips upon the ſea, then let it be as warrantable for us to preach and to teach in ſhips as in Churches; if he taught upon the ſand or ſea ſhore, then let it be as lawfull to teach on the ſand as in the ſhip; if he taught on mountains or hils, then let it be as warrantable to preach5 on the top of a hill as on the ſand; if he taught in private houſes, then let it be as lawfull to preach in a houſe or barn as on the top of a hill; if he prayed in the fields or wilderneſſe, then let it be as warrantable for us to pray in the fields and wilderneſſe, woods or groves as in Churches, &c. If he choſe Fiſhermen, Mechanick Tradeſmen, or the like, to be his Diſciples and preachers to his people, then let it be as warrantable for us to chuſe Paſtors and teachers that are full of the Spirit, of Fiſhermen, Shoomakers, Hatters, &c. And this is the ſafeſt and trueſt manner of Doctrine and Diſcipline to be received by his example.
Truely brother I perceive that you are full of the Spirit, I approve of your Order for Doctrine and Diſcipline, I pray go forward and ſpeak your minde concerning a certain form of Government to be eſtabliſhed in this kingdome, for the due and pure obſervance of this your Doctrine and Diſcipline preſcribed.
Indeed brother I hope I ſhall neither ſpeak nor do any thing but as I ſhall be lead and directed by the Spirit, and touching your next requeſt, I conceive it no wayes meet to have any particular Government in the Church, but every man to govern his aſſembly according to his ſpirit, following likewiſe the example of Chriſt to his Apoſtles, when they ſtrived for ſuperiority one over and above another, who reproved them for the ſame, and made them all Governours alike; ſo would I have it that one man might not lord it over his brethren, being all members of one body, and every one permitted to teach in the Church according to the gifts of Propheſie and Revelation, and if any in the Church be propheſying or preaching, and one that ſtands by hath a clearer gift or revelation, he to ſpeak and declare the ſame, and the other that taught before to hold his peace, according to the rule of Saint Paul, 1 Cor. 14.29, 30, 31. Let the Prophets ſpeak two or three, and let the other4〈1 page duplicate〉5〈1 page duplicate〉6judge. 30. If any thing be revealed to another that ſitteth by, let the firſt hold his peace. 31. For ye may all propheſie one by one, that all may be comforted. So it appears there is no ſupremacy in teachers, all men without degrees, or Univerſity Scholerſhip, if they have the gift and ſpirit of propheſie, may preach and teach the people and are onely to be eſteemed according to the excellency of their gifts and holineſſe of life, let him be of what occupation or profeſſion whatſoever.
Well brother no more of this. Now let us conſider of the beſt way to effect this intended work of Reformation and eſtabliſhing of our Religion in this kingdome.
As I ſaid before, joyne our ſelves for our better advantage in outward appearance, in fraternity with the ſeverall ſects aforementioned.
But how if the adverſe party be ſo obſtinate, and the great ones in high places be ſo perverſe that they will by no means agree to our deſire nor conforme themſelves to our Religion,
Then is it lawfull to take up Armes and by force eſtabliſh Religion and bring to condigne puniſhment the oppoſers thereof, cut down the tall Cedars, ſpirituall wickedneſſe in high places, rather then our Religion ſhould be deſtroyed, and Antichriſtianiſme or looſe and formall Proteſtancy be continued in this kingdom, better to puniſh the body by ſtripes then both body and ſoul to periſh by ſinne.
I well approve all that thou halt ſaid. Let us put in action our intention, and ſo God be with you for this time.
And ſo I pray God keep you till our next meeting.